Point Pleasant 15th August 1835

Mr. J. F. Perry -

Dr. Sir

As I have determined not to go to the meeting at Columbia to day it may be well to prevent a misunderstanding of my course to say what it has been and what it is now—

I have been opposed to the plan of taking San Antonio without first consulting the people— It was certainly premature and contrary to the spirit of our education—because we have not been taught to believe, that a few ought to controll the destiny of all—be their motives what they may— In all matters where the all are interested, all should be consulted and by a clearly expressed will of the majority the ballance should be governed— Because I am opposed to the plan, of a few at San Felipi it has been said that "I am a disappointed land speculator" if it ware so it was my misfortune or my good fortune— It matters not— It might also be said that those who were so anxious for the plan of the few at San Felipi "ware not disappointed land speculators" the one would as likely be true as the other—but I impune no mans motives this is not the way to get at truth— one should not be too ready to suspect the motives of each other— It is certain that there is some excitement in the country— I am sorry for it— I am sure I know the cause—but how are we to remedy it—not by strife among ourselves— we must be united— and there is but one way that I can see to effect that object—a meeting of the people by their delligates— If they desire to defeat the "land speculators" no better way can be thought of that I can see— The people will have all in their own hands— I am not at present in favour of a convention, because I think we shall be alone—but if the majority say convention so say I but I am for disunion with our other half, who have made it their business for the last 2 or 3 years to ruin us— I am not in favour of supporting any of the ex state authorities—but shall be in favour of a clean turne and declare for our selves— We cannot make parte of a defense— We must go the whole or none at all— I am persuaded the people will not fight for those who have been their worst enemies— They have all in their own hands and can do as they please I will go with my countrymenright or wrong— all I have shall be pledged for our common defense

Benja. F. Smith [Rubric]

[Addressed:] Mr. Jas. F. Perry Columbia