Stephen F Austin to General Gaines, 07-27-1836


Summary: Explaining motives of his letter to President Jackson, July 4. His devotion to Texas. Criticised for advising release of Santa Anna


Peach Point, near Brazoria Texas, July 27 1836

Maj. Gen. E. P. Gain[e]s,

Dr Sir,

I had the honor to write you on the 4th instant on the subject of the indians, and also in relation to the termination of the war between Texas and Mexico, through the mediation of the U. S. on the basis of the full recognition of the independence of Texas by Mexico

I have just been informed that Gen. Santa Anna has written to you on this subject— I have not seen his letter, nor have I seen or had any intercourse with him since I wrote you last, and can therefore say nothing as to his present views or ideas.

When I saw him last, on the 4th July, he stated to me that he wished to terminate the war on the basis of a full and immediate acknowledgement of the independence of Texas by Mexico, and that he wished to effect this object through the mediation of the U. S. I observed that the proper mode of obtaining such mediation was by an application from the Govt. of Mexico to that of the U. S.— He replyed that such an application would be made by him the moment he was at liberty and could return to mexico and resume the government. I answered that his release was impossible without such previous guarantees as would fully satisfy the people and Army of Texas, and even put it out of his power, or the power of the Govt. of Mexico to deviate, were they disposed to do so, and that I could see but one guarantee that would effectually do this, which was that of the U. S. Govt. He said he would write to Gen. Jackson, I advised him to do so, believing that it would, at least, be a kind of opening of the Subject, which would lead to a corespondence of some character between the U. S. and Mexico, that might result favourably for Texas. In any event I could not see that any harm could by any possibility grow out of it—

Under this view of the matter I wrote to Gen. Jackson At the same time, and gave him all the information I could on the subject—

I have no concealments or Mistery in any matter connected with this, or any other subject of public interest to Texas— I am nothing more than an individual citizen of this country, but I feel a more lively interest for its welfare than can be expressed—one that is greatly superior to all pecuniary or personal views of any kind— The prosperity of Texas has been the object of my labors, the idol of my existence—it has assumed the character of a religion, for the guidance of my thoughts and actions, for fifteen years— Influenced by this controuling principle, I wish to see the war ended as speedily as possible, to avert farther evils from this people, and I also wish to see Texas annexed to the U. S. as I believe that to be the most effectual and speedy mode of procuring for its inhabitants that security and stability in civil Gov. which alone can compensate them for their past sufferings therefore have no hesitation in saying to you and to every one else, that I wish for the intervention of the U. S. Govt, in the affairs of Texas—that I have endeavor'd to procure its intervention, and that this was my only object in advising Gen. Santa Anna to apply to Gen. Jackson, and my only object in writing to him and to You on the 4th instant.

Rumor and excited passions or political Slander have accused me of a desire to save the life of Gen. Santa Anna in violation of justice which demands his execution as a murderer— I have had no hand in saving him and he was saved by the armistice entered into by Gen. Sam Houston on the 22d April, and by the Cabinet of Texas afterwards— I have no undue sympathy for Santa Anna— My sympathies are all for Texas and her inhabitants, and if Santa Anna can be used to end the war, I am willing to use him on the principle of public good, and more especially after he was saved and treated with on the field of battle and received as a prisoner of war and treated as such by the Civil and military authorities of the country. But I am not willing to turn him loose without previous, and ample, and sufficient, and unquestionable guarantees— The only one of this character that I can see, is the guarantee of the U. S. and I have endeavored (so far as I have had anything to do with this matter) to use Gen. Santa for the purpose of obtaining it

Many here have objected that in my letter to Gen. Jackson and to you of 4 instant, I stated that I believed Santa Anna was sincere in his promises to end the war and acknowledge our independence— The object of those letters was to procure the guarantee of the U. S. and it would have been a St[r]ange thing in me, to have said to Gen. Jackson, and, to you, that I did not believe in Santa Anna's promises, and at the same time Asked you to Guarantee them— I consider it quite immaterial whether he is sincere or not, if through his promises the guarantee of the U. S. can be obtained, for that very guarantee would make him secure by compelling him, to comply, as he well knows—

I consider that there is but one doubt or difficulty about this matter, which is whether Santa Anna's power and influence in Mexico would be sufficient to enable him to procure an acknowledgment of the independence of Texas— This doubt I think is well founded, and that it can only be removed by some official act of the Govt. of Mexico that would be binding on the nation, such an official act I thought might be procured through the mediation of the U. S. while Santa Anna's friends and party were still in power, and his letter to Gen. Jackson I thought might open a door to obtain it—

Such have been and are the motives which influence me

S. F. Austin